Potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) cv. Santé was grown over two years under both conventional and organic fertiliser and crop protection regimes. The tuber metabolome was analysed using mass-spectrometry (MS) based approaches, principally Liquid Chromatography (LC)-MS and Gas Chromatography (GC)-MS. Data were analysed using Principal Components Analysis (PCA) and ANalysis Of VAriance (ANOVA) to assess any differences between production practices. GC-MS analysis of non-polar metabolites did not detect any statistically significant differences, but GC-MS analysis of polar compounds identified 83 metabolites showing significant differences in the metabolome between the fertiliser treatments. Of the 62 metabolites that were less abundant in tuber samples from organic compared with conventionally fertilised crops, consistent year on year differences were dominated by free amino acids. The effect on free amino acids is associated with the lower nitrogen (N) content of the organically grown potatoes in this instance (50% lower than for conventional production). LC-MS provided indications that levels of certain glycoalkaloids may be lower under the organic fertiliser regime in one growing season. Differences associated with the crop protection measures used were much less consistent, and relatively small, compared with the fertiliser effects found.